I suppose they could be. However, the parts I have obtained from him show
no evidence of being quality rejects at all. The orange meeple set that I obtained (because I play orange in
Settlers!
) are actually IMHO as good as (if not better) than those packaged with the game! I have obtained the
Clans huts and other wooden pieces from him, again with no quality issues. I would not hesitate in using Peter again for my wooden game parts.
On the other hand, I ordered just 30 meeples (in various colours) from
Meeple People and had three 'armless' meeples in that one shipment alone (that's 10% rejects!!!).
I'm just waiting for someone to supply me an orange wagon, barn and mayor! I hope i'm not waiting too long.