Trader category

[CKorfmann]

I was thinking that perhaps on the download page it might be appropriate to have a subcategory for trade good expansions.  There are a good number of those at this point. 

[loganmann1]

I think a traders category is a great idea.  I asked some questions in another thread about suggestions on where to start with fan made expansions and the discussion quickly turned to and focused on the numerous trader expansions there are. I still haven't had a chance to try them yet but I greatly appreciated the advice.

And if a reorganization of the downloads page were to happen to include trade good expansions, I would also suggest a possible section for 1 or 2 tile expansions and expansions that can be played as just 2 tiles.  There may not be a lot of them but I know I found CC originally looking for ideas for my 2 creativity tiles and would bet a number of others may have found it the same way.  It might help people get started without feeling overwhelmed by 150 forest tiles.

So this would include expansions like:
- Kings Gate
- Archery Tournament
- Market Commons
- Roman Road and Roman Temple
- Lord of the Manor (Noted that it can be just one city and one farm castle until you add more expansions)
- The Medieval Expansion could be noted as well since its designed as several small expansions

I guess the same could be accomplished just by including the tile count in the descriptions like the forest does.

This probably isn't that big a deal but it crossed my mind after getting all the advice I got.

[CKorfmann]

There may not be a lot of them but I know I found CC originally looking for ideas for my 2 creativity tiles and would bet a number of others may have found it the same way.

That's exactly how I found the site.  I've suggested the same thing before.

[loganmann1]

These all got suggested to me as Trader expansions...are there any more? I guess there are some that are specific to large fan mades as well...

- Fruit Traders
- Cocoa Traders
- Foreign Traders
- Apothecaries and Tithes
- Mills and Bakeries
- Lavender Fields
- Gold Mines
- Cleric and Serf (Cloister Tokens are really just marker to keep track with but the bonus is the same)

[Gwommy]

There may not be a lot of them but I know I found CC originally looking for ideas for my 2 creativity tiles and would bet a number of others may have found it the same way.

That's exactly how I found the site.  I've suggested the same thing before.

LoL!  Same here! (about how I found this site)

[loganmann1]

There may not be a lot of them but I know I found CC originally looking for ideas for my 2 creativity tiles and would bet a number of others may have found it the same way.

That's exactly how I found the site.  I've suggested the same thing before.

LoL!  Same here! (about how I found this site)

It would be interesting to run a poll asking how people found CC with options like "looking for 2 tile creativity ideas," "looking for rules clarification," "found a link/reference on such and such a site" (please say where below), etc etc etc.

On that topic it might be interesting to run a poll to see what types of expansions people would like to see more of like "Trade good expansions," "new features," "more meeples" etc etc etc and see where the interest lies.  OF course that would be more valuable if it wasn't the same couple a dozen members who actually make all these expansions answering the polls.  You'd need response from more guests and things to make that valuable.

[Novelty]

When you guys get the time, go have a look at the downloads page and thank Gwommy for the icons.

Authors, please let me know if you want me to add/remove icons for the expansions you've made (and only those you've made).

[skipboris]

What about an icon for new pieces?  I like the other ions.

[loganmann1]

Thanks Gwommy, thats great.

[meepleater]

They look good. The Two Towers has one honey trade good, is it considered an expansion with trade goods (they are not new, only expanded slightly)?

[Novelty]

TTT updated with the trade goods icon.

[CKorfmann]

Looks good.  I like it!

[Novelty]

More of Gwommy's icon goodness are now on the downloads page.  Thank you very much Sir Gwommy

[loganmann1]

I really like all the icons that have been added and see that some of the icons are for "requires Forests" or "requires Mountains."  Though I don't want to flood the downloads page, should there be icons for official expansions a fan made may add to and/or require?  Like Duel Dragons requires P&D, Black Tower requires the Tower, and there are several others.  Not a lot that are but if theres an icon for the fan mades it seems like the official expansions ought to be listed.  But like I said, I wouldn't want to flood the downloads page and maybe there are to few to be worth it.  Maybe just one icon for expansions that require specific official expansions. 

[Gwommy]

That's probably going a little far.  Although, I was thinking that there should be an icon for expansions that use extra meeple.  Granted, there is a category for them, but there are others that need extra meeple hiding in the ocean and forest lists.

And I can't figure out what determines whether the expansion gets the '2' tile icon or not.  I see it's next to many expansions that has 6 tiles or more.