Inn and Stable Owners

[Joff]

Sorry, I missed that.

The reason for asking is that I am thinking of donating a small set of travel meeples to the currently running contest, but I don't think I have that many spare , and with them I wanted to supply a printed ruleset for using them. Another option I have are wicke's The Kids are Growing Up, but I am using one of wicke's creations for a contest prize already (The House of Valois - using 2 large gold followers).

[ShadowP68]

Thanks novelty, I will get those changes made.

Joff, I have it starting with 4 travel meeples to start with when using the regular Carcassonne with the expansion Inns and Cathedrels. If a player has more expansions they can use more.

[ShadowP68]

Question,

Should I leave the scoring for Innkeepers for unfinished roads as Zero points (to keep it challenging to finnish roads) or change it to one point for each Inn?

 

[Novelty]

I would leave it as 0 points.

[ShadowP68]

http://www.mediafire.com/file/q2yzxmdotij/Inn and Stable Owners.pdf

Got the revised rules up for review let me know what need to be tweeked?

[meepleater]

"When a road along which an inn is completed each player with an inkeeper along the road scores 3 points for each inkeeper along that road.

That sentance is worded a bit strangely. Also, is that for each inkeeper along the road (as you stated) or each inkeeper of your colour along the road?
Also, I think 9 points for a stable is a bit much, as that is the same (and with livestock, more) than cloisters, which play a more integral part of Carcassonne, are worth. Maybe for each orthogonal tile instead of adjacent?

[Novelty]

Sorry, meepleater, that's my bad I think for not suggesting it.  Yes, it shoudl be "of their colour" in there somewhere.  A comma is also missing after the word completed there.  So the actual Scoring sectioon should read something like:

When a road along which an inn is completed, each player with an inkeeper along the road scores 3 points for each of their innkeeper along that road.  If an Innkeeper the player scoring the Innkeeper(s) also has the most followers on the road, each the Innkeeper receives an additional one point.
At the end of the game, Innkeepers do not score any points if the road that it is on is incomplete.

A stable is completed when the tile it is on is completely surrounded by land tiles. The player with a Stable owner on it earns 8 points (1 for each tile surrounding the Stable). If a A completed stable is completed which includes livestock receives an additional 5 points.  At the end of the game, For an incomplete Stable, the player with the each stable owner earns scores 1 point for each land tile surrounding it. The player does not receive and additional 5 points if the stable with livestock is not finished completed.

Also, commas (highlighted in Red) are missing in the drawing paragraphs (example for Inns shown):

When a player draws a tile with an Inn on it, they may play it as usual. The player may also deploy a follower to the Inn as the Innkeeper, in addition to the other usual actions. You don’t need to have a follower on the road to deploy a follower on the Inn.

[ShadowP68]

Got the latest update to the Inn Owners and Ranchers.

http://www.mediafire.com/file/mz3hyz0tmlt/Inn Owners and Ranchers.pdf

Let me know if there is anything else that needs to be changed.

[Novelty]

Also, commas (highlighted in Red) are missing in the drawing paragraphs (example for Inns shown):

When a player draws a tile with an Inn on it, they may play it as usual. The player may also deploy a follower to the Inn as the Innkeeper, in addition to the other usual actions. You don’t need to have a follower on the road to deploy a follower on the Inn.

You need to add in the 2 commas for the Stable section, and then rev it up to 1.0 and you're ready to go final!  Good job!

[ShadowP68]

Sorry about the long time to post the final but here it is.

http://www.mediafire.com/file/nym2xtnxyoh/Inn and Stable Owners.pdf

[Novelty]

Good job!  Thanks for working on this!  Merit point awarded!  It's now available on the Public Downloads page.