|
Title: A Q: of PIG HERDS in AnnotatedRules and Consolidated Tile Reference Post by: cori226 on August 25, 2008, 09:35:26 pm in AnnotatedRules Page 68 and the last Page of Consolidated Tile Reference, there was said that have only 1 PIG HERDS card in the entire carcassonne game.
But I found another 1 PIG HERDS card in GQ11 (gggg card) ??? have any PIG HERDS in the other expansion? (or only river II and GQ11??) ??? ??? Title: Re: A Q: of PIG HERDS in AnnotatedRules and Consolidated Tile Reference Post by: Deatheux on August 25, 2008, 09:55:23 pm this may be an pig herd but has been dismissed by John Sweeny, so this only a flat field(ffff) tile.
Title: Re: A Q: of PIG HERDS in AnnotatedRules and Consolidated Tile Reference Post by: cori226 on August 25, 2008, 11:07:17 pm this may be an pig herd but has been dismissed by John Sweeny, so this only a flat field(ffff) tile. Sorry, who is John Sweeny ... and the meaning of "dismissed" is dismissed all the pig herds or only the GQ 11's pig herd and what is the total number of pig herds?? Title: Re: A Q: of PIG HERDS in AnnotatedRules and Consolidated Tile Reference Post by: Tobias on August 26, 2008, 12:17:02 am Officially it is not a pig herd.
Still, I would wager a guess and say that for most people it is. Title: Re: A Q: of PIG HERDS in AnnotatedRules and Consolidated Tile Reference Post by: mjharper on August 26, 2008, 02:04:56 am The FAQ is here (http://carc.mjharper.de/page14/page14.html#As_far_as_the_tile_with_pigs_on):
Q (John Sweeney (http://www.modernjive.com/carcassonne/carcassonne.htm)): As far as the tile with pigs on it is concerned—do you have an official ruling? I understand from Hans im Glück that these are your tiles rather than theirs, so I guess you are the final arbiter! A (Jay Tummelson): Yes, I am—and this is just a field—no special points for the pigs and cows in it—sorry. So, the story is this: when GQ11 came out everybody just assumed that the tile that looks like a pig-herd tile was actually a pig-herd tile. But John Sweeney, who runs another FAQ site, wrote to the Jay Tummelson of RGG—who produced that expansion—and asked for confirmation. He denied that it was. The expansion was supposed to have no new rules, and the so-called pig-herd tile is really just a pretty picture. Since that's an official ruling, I have to add it to the CAR. Still, as Tobias said, I'd guess that most people uses it as a pig-herd tile, at least when you have the other one in play as well. Title: Re: A Q: of PIG HERDS in AnnotatedRules and Consolidated Tile Reference Post by: cori226 on August 28, 2008, 02:11:12 am Since that's an official ruling, I have to add it to the CAR. Still, as Tobias said, I'd guess that most people uses it as a pig-herd tile, at least when you have the other one in play as well. I think I will use it as a pig-herd when I play wiv my friends such as (http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y99/cori226/carc01.jpg) and (http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y99/cori226/carc02.jpg) I will use it as ONE CITY and ONE ROAD because the pic told me wht is it :) and I no need to tell my friend the grand history of carcassonne |